by jboullion | Jan 28, 2016 | Uncategorized
“Shaping the Utility of the Future,” our fifth Annual Renewable Energy Policy Summit, was another huge success for the organization. Held January 21, 2016, it featured thought and action leaders from across the country and leaders from Wisconsin’s utilities and renewable energy industry
The event covered the gamut of opportunities and challenges for increasing renewable energy in Wisconsin. From both the number of attendees, and their feedback so far, we had the best Summit yet!
– 295 registered
– 265 attended
– 56 business and organizational sponsors
– 17 exhibitors
Following some opening remarks from RENEW’s Board President, Carl Siegrist, U.S. Congressman
Mark Pocan gave our audience a warm welcome to Madison, and spoke about the job creation potential of renewable energy and his leadership in Washington, D.C.RENEW’s Tyler Huebner gave a review of 2015’s renewable energy policy impacts and a brief look forward to 2016’s top priorities. Then, we handed the stage over to our opening keynote speaker.
Mary Powell, CEO of Green Mountain Power: “The Energy Company of the Future”
Mary started her speech with her own personal story. She grew up thinking she would become an artist, with no thought that she would ever become an executive. She then transitioned into the evolution that she brought to Green Mountain Power, first starting with a cultural change. She moved the executives out of an office building and into a converted maintenance building next to the line workers.
That lead to the transition in the electricity side of the business. Mary’s business background outside of the utility industry taught her that the customer is king, and Green Mountain Power’s customer surveys showed customers wanted low cost energy, and more renewables. Bucking the traditional thinking that low cost and renewables don’t go together, she challenged her team to figure out how to deliver what their customers want.
The GMP result is “stacking the benefits” as Mary calls it – finding ways to aggregate all the benefits of distributed generation in a way that can lower costs for everyone. You can learn more about how Green Mountain Power is incorporating renewable and distributed energy, click here.
New Business Models & Policy Impacts: Wisconsin Utility Perspectives
Brian Rude of Dairyland Power, Deborah Erwin of Xcel Energy, and Kevin Westhuis of River Falls comprised representatives of cooperative, investor-owned, and municipal electricity providers for our utility panel.
Moderated by Eric Callisto of Michael Best & Friedrich law firm, the panelists discussed their community solar initiatives and additional renewable projects outlook. They also discussed the key policy issues at hand: the U.S. EPA’s Clean Power Plan, distributed generation, the future of the state’s renewable portfolio standard (or RPS).
Awards & Recognition Ceremony
Over lunch, RENEW’s Michael Vickerman lead the recognition of over 40 of 2015’s best renewable energy projects. Three categories were recognized:
– Community solar, featuring five electricity providers who installed community solar programs in 2015
– 30 Largest projects, featuring 29 solar and 1 biogas project, the largest renewable energy systems installed in 2015
– “10 to Remember,” highlighting unique partnerships and stories of ten solar installations, from large businesses to community solar to non-profit donation-led models.
James Tong, Spruce Finance, “The Democratization of Energy and the Networked Grid”
James Tong came into the renewable energy space trying to figure out how to increase solar installations. He came to the conclusion that working with utilities, and sharing both the utilities natural advantages and the solar industries advantages together, will lead to the most solar at the lowest cost.
After realizing that many utilities will have a hard time making the evolution into solar, for both business and regulatory reasons, he has set out to establish a more democratized electricity grid that would enable market-based transactions for distributed resources. That grid would behave much like the Apple “App Store,” with the utility owning and maintaining the grid as a platform, where valuable third-party providers could provide services. View James’ PowerPoint here.
Driving Markets: Perspectives from the Renewable Energy Industry (presented by S.C. Johnson)
Our day’s final panel featured experts from three critical renewable energy technologies:
– Chris Kunkle, Wind on the Wires
– Steve Dvorak, DVO Digesters (biogas)
– Adam Gusse, H&H Solar
– Amy Heart, Sunrun & The Alliance for Solar Choice
These panelists discussed the market opportunity for their technology, the market barriers, and the policies in Wisconsin that would enable these technologies to grow. The key policy for wind appears to be the Clean Power Plan, which Chris Kunkle said could lead to 2,000 MW or more of wind generation (Wisconsin currently has about 648 MW). Solar has benefited from Focus on Energy and strong net metering policies, but these policies and programs need to be continued. Also, Adam Gusse highlighted working together with utilities on interconnection as an area where time and cost can be saved. Steve Dvorak of DVO highlighted the various countries and states his company is working in, and the need to re-focus on biogas development in Wisconsin as a win-win-win for renewable energy, our dairy farmers, and our lakes and air.
We hope you will join us next year for another great Renewable Energy Policy Summit!
Check out media coverage of the Summit below:
“Solar Outlook Brightens in Wisconsin” Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Tom Content
“Vermont utility exec touts green power, lower electric bills,” Wisconsin State Journal, Judy Newman
“Solar Energy Grows,” Wheeler News Service (Radio), WHBL Sheboygan
“Utility Officials Say Shift Away from Coal Will Be Gradual” WisBusiness.com
“Renewable Energy Proponents Hope for A ‘Revolution’ in Wisconsin” Wisconsin Public Radio
by jboullion | Jan 18, 2016 | Uncategorized
Immediate release
January 18, 2016
More information
Tyler Huebner, Executive Director
608.255.4044 x 1
tyler.huebner@renewwisconsin.org
2015’s Best Renewable Energy Projects to Receive Recognition This Week
The biggest and best renewable energy installations in 2015 are set to be recognized at Renew Wisconsin’s annual Renewable Energy Summit this Thursday, January 21st in Madison. The recognition ceremony will take place at 12:45pm, during lunch. The Summit will be held at the Monona Terrace in Madison; registration starts at 8am and the program runs from 9:00 AM to 3:30 PM.
It was a breakout year for solar energy. Over three times as many solar panels were installed in 2015 as the prior year, and the most ever in the state: 7.5 megawatts worth, enough to supply over 900 Wisconsin homes’ annual electricity usage.
The recognition will be bestowed across three categories:
Community Solar, featuring five utility providers who instituted projects where customers can share in the solar production from one centrally located, larger solar array.
2015 Utility-Sponsored Community Solar
Projects in Wisconsin
|
Electric Provider
|
Location
|
Installation Contractor
|
Project Size (in kW DC)
|
Eau Claire Energy Cooperative
|
Fall River
|
Able Energy
|
865
|
River Falls Utilities and WPPI Energy
|
River Falls
|
H&H Solar
|
250
|
New Richmond Utilities and WPPI Energy
|
New Richmond
|
H&H Solar
|
250
|
Taylor Electric Cooperative
|
Medford
|
Unknown
|
100
|
Clark Electric Cooperative
|
Greenwood
|
Unknown
|
53
|
Total
Capacity
1,518 kW
|
Noteworthy Solar Collaborations, featuring ten solar projects where creative teams, financing, or customer marketing were utilized to make the projects happen.
Wisconsin
Renewable Energy Honor Roll
Class of 2015
Projects – Noteworthy Solar Collaborations
|
Project Participants (including installer)
|
Project Location(s)
|
Project Size(s)
(in kW)
|
Customer category
|
Central Storage Warehouse/
SunPeak
|
Madison
|
741
|
Food
|
New Richmond + River Falls
Utilities/WPPI Energy/SunVest
|
New Richmond, River Falls
|
500 (2 250 kW arrays in each community)
|
Utility community solar
|
Blenker Building Systems/
Central Waters Brewery/Jensen Center/North Wind Renewable Energy
|
Amherst
|
220 (3 systems)
|
Food + manufacturing / non-profit
|
Fair Share Coalition/ H&H
Solar
|
Across south central WI
|
197 (17 systems)
|
Farm/food
|
Infinity Retail Services/
Kettle View
|
Turtle Lake
|
50 in 2015 (+ 50 kW wind in 2012)
|
Manufacturing
|
City of Milwaukee/ MREA/Arch
Electric
|
Milwaukee
|
84 (26 systems)
|
Local govt. (group buy)
|
Kickapoo Coffee Roasters/ VEDC/Ethos
Green Power
|
Viroqua
|
25
|
Food
|
Union Cab/ Legacy Solar
Cooperative/ Midwest Solar Power
|
Madison
|
19 (+5 in 2012)
|
Transportation
|
Northwest WI Renewable Energy Learning Center/ Legacy Solar
|
Osceola
|
10
|
Non-profit
|
Spring Hill Farm/ North Wind
RE
|
Prairie Farm
|
9
|
Farm/food (member donations)
|
Largest Installations, denoting the 31 projects with the largest power capacity that were installed in the year. (Note that some of these are also included in the above two categories.) This category features 30 solar projects alongside Statz B Dairy, where a
“biogas digester” was installed which converts cow manure into usable
biogas for electricity.
Wisconsin Renewable
Energy Honor Roll
Class of 2015
Projects
|
Thirty-one largest renewable generators installed this
year
|
Customer
|
Location
|
Resource
|
Utility
|
Project Size (in kWDC)
|
Contractor (location)
|
Forest County
Potawatomi
|
Crandon, Milwaukee (15 locations)
|
Solar
|
WPS, We Energies
|
922
|
SunVest Solar
(Pewaukee)
|
Eau Claire Energy
Cooperative
|
Fall Creek
|
Solar
|
ECEC
|
863
|
Able Energy (River Falls)
|
Central Storage
Warehouse
|
Madison
|
Solar
|
Madison Gas & Electric
|
741
|
SunPeak
(Madison)
|
Statz Brothers
|
Sun Prairie
|
Biogas (dairy)
|
Alliant-WPL
|
600
|
DVO (Chilton)
|
Letterhead Press
|
New Berlin
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
337
|
SunPeak
|
Rockwell
Automation
|
Mequon
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
263
|
H&H Solar
(Madison)
|
River Falls
Utilities
|
River Falls
|
Solar
|
RFU (muni)
|
250
|
H&H Solar
|
New Richmond
Utilities
|
New Richmond
|
Solar
|
NRU (muni)
|
250
|
H&H Solar
|
Sisters of St.
Agnes
|
Fond du Lac
|
Solar
|
Alliant-WPL
|
248
|
Eland Electric
(Green Bay)
|
Darlington School
District
|
Darlington
|
Solar
|
Alliant-WPL
|
156
|
SunVest Solar
|
O&H Danish
Bakery
|
Mt. Pleasant
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
152
|
SunVest Solar
|
Crystal Ball
Farms
|
Osceola
|
Solar
|
Xcel -NSPW
|
151
|
Next Energy Solution (Spooner)
|
Jewelers Mutual
Insurance Company
|
Neenah
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
128.5
|
Energize, LLC (Winneconne)
|
Stieglitz Dairy
|
Greenwood
|
Solar
|
Clark Electric Cooperative
|
105.3
|
Next Energy Solution
|
Central Waters
Brewery
|
Amherst
|
Solar
|
Alliant-WPL
|
100.8
|
North Wind RE (Stevens Point)
|
Blenker Building
Systems
|
Amherst
|
Solar
|
Alliant-WPL
|
100.8
|
North Wind RE
|
Isthmus
Engineering
|
Madison
|
Solar
|
MG&E
|
99.5
|
H&H Solar
|
Precision Plus
|
Elkhorn
|
Solar
|
Elkhorn (muni)
|
99
|
Kettle View RE (Silver Creek)
|
Animart
|
Beaver Dam
|
Solar
|
Alliant-WPL
|
99
|
Kettle View RE
|
Organic Valley
|
Cashton
|
Solar
|
Cashton (muni)
|
95
|
Full Spectrum Solar (Madison)
|
Corrim Company
|
Oshkosh
|
Solar
|
WI Public Service
|
92
|
SunPeak
|
Components
Company
|
Brookfield
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
78
|
Convergence Energy (Lake Geneva)
|
Parmenter
Circle Apts.
|
Middleton
|
Solar
|
MG&E
|
72
|
Full Spectrum Solar
|
Oregon Middle
School
|
Oregon
|
Solar
|
Alliant
|
62
|
Full Spectrum Solar
|
Outpost Nat’l
Foods
|
Mequon
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
56.3
|
SunVest Solar
|
Evergreen Credit
Union
|
Neenah
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
56
|
Eland Electric
|
Clark Electric
Cooperative
|
Greenwood
|
Solar
|
Clark Electric
|
53.3
|
10K Solar/ Viking Electric (MN)
|
Excel Patterns
|
Bonduel
|
Solar
|
We Energies
|
50.4
|
Eland Electric
|
Infinity Retail
Services
|
Turtle Lake
|
Solar
|
Xcel-NSPW
|
50
|
Kettle View RE
|
Borah Teamwear
|
Coon Valley
|
Solar
|
Xcel-NSPW
|
50
|
Ethos Green Power (Viroqua)
|
Reynolds Storage
and Transfer
|
Madison
|
Solar
|
MG&E
|
48
|
SunPeak
|
“Solar energy is growing at exponential rates across the country and we are pleased that Wisconsin is sharing in this American success story with the many great projects installed in 2015,” said Tyler Huebner, Renew Wisconsin’s Executive Director. “However, our Honor Roll shows another stark fact: as a state, we need to prioritize the growth of wind, bioenergy, and hydro power as well as solar in 2016 and beyond. These homegrown energy sources will make Wisconsin better for future generations.”
For more information on the 2016 summit program agenda, speakers, and registration, please visit http://renewwisconsin.org/2016_Summit/
by jboullion | Jan 14, 2016 | Uncategorized
Immediate release
January 14, 2016
More information
Tyler Huebner, Executive Director
608.255.4044 x 1
tyler.huebner@renewwisconsin.org
Solar Power Hits the Big Time in Wisconsin
Newest Large Array Energizes Waukesha County Manufacturer
In yet another demonstration of solar energy’s growing appeal to commercial and industrial customers, Letterhead Press recently joined the growing roster of Wisconsin companies turning to the sun to power their operations.
Located in New Berlin, Letterhead Press now derives about 25% of the electricity consumed at its 120,000-square foot facility on Ryerson Road from a 300 kilowatt (AC) solar array. Situated on a parking lot behind the production facility, Letterhead’s array was the fourth largest solar system installed in Wisconsin last year (see table below), and is now the largest in Waukesha County.
The facility was dedicated Tuesday at an event organized by Letterhead Press and featuring remarks from Letterhead Press CEO Mike Graf, Lt. Governor Rebecca Kleefisch, Waukesha County Executive Paul Farrow, New Berlin Mayor Dave Ament, Sun Peak (the solar project developer and contractor), Focus on Energy, the Wisconsin Manufacturing Extension Partnership, Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation, and RENEW Wisconsin.
“2015 was a banner year for solar generation in the Badger State,” said RENEW Wisconsin’s Executive Director Tyler Huebner. “Growth was especially strong among larger customers looking to take advantage of solar power’s declining costs to help them control their escalating energy expenses.”
Solar was the fastest growing generation resource in Wisconsin in 2015, expanding from 18 megawatts (MW) at the beginning of the year to more than 25 MW at year’s end. Solar power expanded even more vigorously elsewhere in the United States, with 7,500 MW–the equivalent of Wisconsin’s increase 1,000 times over–coming on line last year.
In addition to being a cost-effective source of electricity for business and institutional customers, solar power supports a national industry that employs more than 208,000 people, according to the most recent solar jobs report conducted by The Solar Foundation. Solar industry employment grew 12 times faster than the overall U.S. workforce. About 1,900 solar jobs are located in Wisconsin, according to the previous year’s report.
Letterhead Press will be one of several dozen solar generation owners recognized at RENEW Wisconsin’s fifth annual Renewable Energy Policy Summit set for Thursday, January 21, 2016, at Monona Terrace in Madison. The theme of the event, “Shaping the Utility of the Future,” will delve into the rapidly changing electric utility environment and examine business models under which utilities and customers can work bring more clean energy into the Wisconsin energy mix.
For more information on the 2016 summit program agenda, speakers, and registration, please visit http://renewwisconsin.org/2016_Summit/
31 Largest Solar
Electric Systems Installed in Wisconsin in 2015
|
Customer
|
Location
|
Utility
|
Project Size (in kWDC)
|
Contractor (location)
|
Forest County Potawatomi
|
Crandon (15 locations), Milwaukee
|
WPS, We Energies
|
922
|
SunVest Solar
(Pewaukee)
|
Eau Claire Energy Cooperative
|
Fall Creek
|
ECEC
|
863
|
Able Energy (River Falls)
|
Central Storage Warehouse
|
Madison
|
Madison Gas & Electric
|
741
|
SunPeak
(Madison)
|
Letterhead Press
|
New Berlin
|
We Energies
|
337
|
SunPeak
|
Rockwell Automation
|
Mequon
|
We Energies
|
263
|
H&H Solar
(Madison)
|
River Falls Utilities
|
River Falls
|
RFU (muni)
|
250
|
H&H Solar
|
New Richmond Utilities
|
New Richmond
|
NRU (muni)
|
250
|
H&H Solar
|
Sisters of St. Agnes
|
Fond du Lac
|
Alliant-WPL
|
248
|
Eland Electric
(Green Bay)
|
Darlington School District
|
Darlington
|
Alliant-WPL
|
156
|
SunVest Solar
|
O&H Danish Bakery
|
Mt. Pleasant
|
We Energies
|
152
|
SunVest Solar
|
Crystal Ball Farms
|
Osceola
|
Xcel-NSPW
|
151
|
Next Energy Solution (Spooner)
|
Jewelers Mutual Insurance
Company
|
Neenah
|
We Energies
|
128.5
|
Energize, LLC (Winneconne)
|
Stieglitz Dairy
|
Greenwood
|
Clark Electric Cooperative
|
105.3
|
Next Energy Solution
|
Central Waters Brewery
|
Amherst
|
Alliant-WPL
|
100.8
|
North Wind RE (Stevens Point)
|
Blenker Building Systems
|
Amherst
|
Alliant-WPL
|
100.8
|
North Wind RE
|
Taylor Electric Cooperative
|
Medford
|
Taylor
|
100
|
10K Solar/ Viking Electric
|
Isthmus
Engineering
|
Madison
|
MG&E
|
99.5
|
H&H Solar
|
Precision Plus
|
Elkhorn
|
Elkhorn (muni)
|
99
|
Kettle View RE (Silver Creek)
|
Animart
|
Beaver Dam
|
Alliant-WPL
|
99
|
Kettle View RE
|
Organic Valley
|
Cashton
|
Cashton (muni)
|
95
|
Full Spectrum Solar (Madison)
|
Corrim Company
|
Oshkosh
|
WI Public Service
|
92
|
SunPeak
|
Components Company
|
Brookfield
|
We Energies
|
78
|
Convergence Energy (Lake Geneva)
|
Parmenter Circle Apts.
|
Middleton
|
MG&E
|
72
|
Full Spectrum Solar
|
Oregon Middle School
|
Oregon
|
Alliant
|
62
|
Full Spectrum Solar
|
Outpost Nat’l Foods
|
Mequon
|
We Energies
|
56.3
|
SunVest Solar
|
Evergreen Credit Union
|
Neenah
|
We Energies
|
56
|
Eland Electric
|
Clark Electric Cooperative
|
Greenwood
|
Clark Electric
|
53.3
|
10K Solar/ Viking Electric (MN)
|
Excel Patterns
|
Bonduel
|
We Energies
|
50.4
|
Eland Electric
|
Infinity Retail Services
|
Turtle Lake
|
Xcel-NSPW
|
50
|
Kettle View RE
|
Borah Teamwear
|
Coon Valley
|
Xcel-NSPW
|
49
|
Ethos Green Power (Viroqua)
|
Reynolds Storage and Transfer
|
Madison
|
MG&E
|
48
|
SunPeak
|
Prepared by: RENEW Wisconsin, January 2016
by jboullion | Jan 6, 2016 | Uncategorized
Immediate release
January 6, 2016
More information
Tyler Huebner
Executive Director
608.255.4044 x 1
tyler.huebner@renewwisconsin.org
Keynotes and Agenda Set for January 21st Renewable Energy Policy Summit
Event Aims to Shape the Utility of the Future
RENEW Wisconsin will host its fifth annual Renewable Energy Policy Summit on Thursday, January 21, 2016, at Monona Terrace in Madison. The theme of the event, “Shaping the Utility of the Future,” will delve into the rapidly changing electric utility environment and examine business models under which utilities and customers can bring more clean energy into the Wisconsin energy mix.
The event will feature two excellent keynote speakers:
Mary Powell, President and Chief Executive Officer for Vermont-based Green Mountain Power (GMP) corporation, an investor-owned utility. As CEO of this utility, Mary initiated and implemented a strategic and comprehensive restructuring of GMP to provide low carbon, low cost, and reliable power to its customers. GMP is the first utility in the world to become a member of B Corp, showing a commitment to use energy as a
force for good.
James Tong, Vice President of Strategy and Government Affairs at Spruce Finance, where he leads industry-wide efforts to accelerate deployment of solar energy. He has helped popularize the idea of “grid neutrality” and is a recognized expert on utility integration of distributed energy resources.
After the opening keynote, three panelists representing Wisconsin electric providers and suppliers will offer their insights into the opportunities and challenges for expanding clean energy development in Wisconsin. The panel will feature:
– Deb Erwin, Regulatory Policy Manager, Xcel Energy (WI)
– Brian Rude, Vice President of External and Member Relations, Dairyland Power Cooperative
– Kevin Westhuis, Utility Director, River Falls Utilities
The panel will be moderated by Eric Callisto, a Partner with the law firm of Michael Best and Friedrich LLP, and former Commissioner on the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin.
Between lunch and the afternoon keynote, RENEW will recognize the most noteworthy clean energy installations built in 2015.
Titled “Driving Markets,” the afternoon panel will feature four representatives of renewable energy industries active in Wisconsin.
– Steve Dvorak, president, DVO, Inc. a biogas digester firm (Chilton)
– Adam Gusse, vice president, H&H Solar (Madison)
– Amy Heart, senior manager, public policy, Sunrun, Inc. (Milwaukee)
– Chris Kunkle, Regional Policy Manager, Wind on the Wires (St. Paul, MN)

The panel will be moderated by Susan Crawford, attorney with Cullen Weston Pines & Bach, and a member of RENEW’s Board of Directors.
RENEW Wisconsin’s Executive Director Tyler Huebner says, “We chose this year’s theme to re-start the conversation on the direction of Wisconsin utilities and clean energy. Wisconsinites want more homegrown, renewable energy and our utilities can be winners from the transition, if they can adapt to the technological innovation and evolving customer interests taking place around them. We’re bringing in two of the best leaders in the country as our keynote speakers to explain this transition: Mary Powell, who as a utility CEO is about 5 years into this evolution at Green Mountain Power, and James Tong, who is a thought leader on how the electric grid itself may need to evolve to enable a more widespread, distributed power future.”
Registration rates are $115 for members of RENEW Wisconsin and $145 for non-members. The rate for government employees is $85 and for students is $35. Membership with RENEW starts at $35 for individuals and $200 for businesses and organizations.
For more information on the 2016 program agenda, speakers, and registration, please visit
http://renewwisconsin.org/2016_Summit/
by jboullion | Dec 29, 2015 | Uncategorized
Overview: As 2015 winds down, it is abundantly clear that solar energy is on a roll in Wisconsin.
 |
Outpost Foods in Mequon Solar Installation |
The current year is ending with a flurry of installations and 2016 will start out on a similarly strong footing. The appeal of solar photovoltaic (PV) technology has never been as broad as it is now, stretching from the smallest of residential customers to farms and faith communities and beyond to manufacturers and even some utilities. Declining out-of-pocket installation costs now make solar-generated electricity an affordable energy option for all property owners with good solar exposure.
 |
Borah Teamwear in Coon Valley Solar Installation |
As a result, growing numbers of Wisconsin electricity customers are taking steps to lock in the savings from solar today for their homes and businesses.
This trend begs two questions: what trends and policies are driving the solar energy market right now and how long will this dynamic continue? Going into December, the 30% solar Investment Tax Credit (ITC) had 13 months to go before expiring at the end of next year. In a surprise development, Congress passed a spending bill containing provisions to extend the solar ITC through 2021. On the same day that spending bill cleared Congress (Dec. 18, 2015), President Obama signed it into law. Thanks to this unexpected but very welcome action, the ITC will remain at 30% through the end of 2019, and then decline to 26% in 2020 and to 22% in 2021.
(For more complete information on the renewable energy tax credit landscape going forward, visit the links below:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-12-28/these-will-be-wall-street-s-most-in-demand-positions-next-year
https://cleantechnica.com/2015/12/20/boom-times-ahead-us-clean-power-thanks-oil-lobby/)
Here in Wisconsin, financial support for solar installations is poised to transition away from cash incentives to loans. In 2016 the transition will begin first with prospective commercial solar hosts.
Policy and Market Drivers: The most significant factors propelling solar installation activity through 2015 are outlined below.
– Declining cost of hardware. Installed costs continued falling through 2015, driven mostly by lower module and inverter prices. That trend should continue in 2016 and beyond.
– A 30% Investment Tax Credit (ITC) and accelerated depreciation provisions for new solar energy systems owned by taxpaying entities. These incentives will remain in place through 2021.
– USDA’s Rural Energy for America Program, which offers grants and loan guarantees to qualifying rural businesses up to 25% of a PV system’s installed cost. The next deadline for applications is February 1, 2016. Approximately $50 million is available.
– Focus on Energy, Wisconsin’s ratepayer-funded energy efficiency and renewable energy program. About $5 million in cash rebates were issued in 2015.
Outlook: Rebates up to $2,400 for PV systems serving residential and small commercial customers will continue in 2016. However, the state has no plans at this time to offer cash incentives to commercial and industrial PV system owners in 2016. Instead, Focus on Energy will make available $2,500,000 in low-interest loans beginning in 2016, and will inject the same amount into the forthcoming revolving loan program in 2017 and 2018. Cash rebates for any sector beyond 2016 will hinge on a Public Service Commission decision likely to occur in mid-2016.
Bottom line: Notwithstanding the uncertainties created by Focus on Energy program changes, Wisconsin’s solar market should see solid growth through the end of the decade.
Prepared by RENEW Wisconsin, December 2015
by jboullion | Dec 22, 2015 | Uncategorized
The following appeared on Samantha Williams’ blog appearing on National Resource Defense Council’s Switchboard page. It is an excellent summary of this year’s utility rate cases nationwide and the “trend” of increasing mandatory monthly customer charges on residential electric customers. As she notes below, the tide is turning, even in Wisconsin.
“Even the Wisconsin Commission, the outlier in this discussion, is taking notice,” Williams writes. “In a relative shift from their 2014 decisions, just a few weeks ago commissioners scaled back a fixed fee request from Wisconsin Public Service Corporation and ordered a study.”
The Year in Utility Rate Cases: Mandatory Fee Hikes Retreat as Consumer Voices Pick up Steam
Posted December 17, 2015
Part of NRDC’s Year-End Series Reviewing 2015 Energy Developments
This was a banner year for public push-back on utility proposals across the country that sought to dramatically change how customers are billed for their electricity.
Had the dozens of proposals this year succeeded, many homeowners and businesses would have been shackled with higher upfront fees, before they even turned on the lights. Thankfully, this was also a banner year for prudent, forward-thinking utility commissioners; nearly three-quarters of the orders issued in 2015 either rejected outright higher fixed fees or modified them to be smaller, incremental increases.
But what do these fees mean for consumers and the environment, and why should we build on the success of 2015 and continue to fight in 2016?
Imagine you’re an average single family homeowner. Over the past few years, you’ve tried to “go green” and save money by participating in energy efficiency programs available through your utility. You had new insulation blown into your attic, you caulked your windows and doors, you upgraded to a more efficient refrigerator and washer and dryer.
The savings have started to roll in every month as you see your energy use go down. You’re wasting less energy, cutting your bills, and doing your part to help the environment by conserving energy and lowering emissions.
You’re happy you made these decisions.
Until one day you get a notice in the mail that your utility is increasing the “customer” or “fixed” portion of your bill. This increase is significant, from a current $10 per month to $20. And you notice the difference right away once the fees go into effect: the savings you previously enjoyed from your efficiency investments are seriously diminished, your bills noticeably higher. It’s getting to the point where you’re having a hard time even affording them.
You talk to your neighbor, who has a much larger house that consumes far more energy and you learn that she hasn’t made any of the improvements you have. Yet, somehow, with the new rates in effect, your neighbor is now paying less than she used to, while you are paying more.
How can this be?!?
Mandatory Fixed Fees: The Impacts
It’s really a question of control, costs, and conservation.
Control – When a utility increases its fixed costs, at the same time it typically decreases the variable per/kWh charge that goes up and down as customers change their energy use. This variable charge is the only portion of the bill that customers have the ability to control. Removing this ability disempowers customers, leaving them with fewer options to cut their bills.
Costs – Higher mandatory fees also force higher costs disproportionately onto the people who use the least electricity. The result? Those who consume less energy end up paying more, while the energy hogs get a break on their electric bills.
Conservation – As if this wasn’t enough, these proposals are like kryptonite for clean energy. They remove the incentive for people to conserve energy, lengthening payback periods on energy efficient appliances and solar panels alike. Adding to this dynamic, lower per/kWh charges implicitly tell consumers: We’ll reward you for using more energy, and penalize you for using less.
The Fixed Fee Trend: Waxing and Waning
One of the main drivers of these proposals is the utility desire to shore up their ability to cover costs in the face of a rapidly changing national energy landscape.
This desire is not surprising. Utilities provide a valuable service of ensuring that people have access to reliable electric services, and as we work to modernize the grid and move away from the polluting fossil sources of the last century, it will be critical that–just like any other business–they can recover their reasonable costs of incorporating cleaner energy into the system.
But what is surprising is just how aggressively the industry has pursued the fixed charge approach in particular. Unfortunately, these kinds of rate restructuring proposals have been commonplace over the last few years. In 2015 alone, requests were pending in at least 24 states.

2015 was notable for another reason, though: the unprecedented degree of public opposition to these proposals. Coordinated campaigns waged by the consumer, local government, environmental and solar communities have truly shifted the conversation. NRDC is proud to stand alongside AARP, National Consumer Law Center, NAACP, Vote Solar and many others in this battle.
Thankfully, just as the unfortunate fixed charge “trend” started to gain attention, regulators began responding to the public outcry by holding the line. The industry also appears to be reconsidering, in some states seeking other options to address the rapidly changing energy landscape.
The advocacy community doesn’t always win, but this year–more often than not–we did.
The starting gun for this now-highly visible national effort went off in Wisconsin in the fall of 2014, when the state’s three major investor-owned utilities proposed dramatic rate restructuring, including doubling of fixed charges to the tune of $20 per month. That amount remains–to this day–an outlier for residential fixed charges for regulated electric utilities nationwide. And people were certainly paying attention. Hundreds of customers packed hearing rooms from Milwaukee to Madison. Meanwhile, a diverse group of interveners–including homeowners, clean energy advocates, environmental groups, elected officials, local businesses, local and national consumer groups, along with local sports figures and representatives of the “green Tea Party” movement–demanded the utility go back to the drawing board.
This trend of public engagement caught on in 2015, from New York to California, Missouri to Kentucky.
And while the commissioners in the 2014 Wisconsin cases unfortunately declined to answer the call of hundreds of local voices, they were largely alone. In 2015 far more recognized the detrimental impact of fixed fee increases on homeowners in their states. In Minnesota, for example, the commission rejected Xcel’s fixed fee proposal because that it would “place too little emphasis on the need to set rates to encourage conservation.” In the Ameren Missouri case, the commission left the monthly charge unchanged, making clear that customers “should have as much control over the amount of their bills as possible so that they can reduce their monthly expenses by using less power, either for economic reasons or because of a general desire to conserve energy.” The list of prudent commission decisions goes on and on.
The national media also took notice. Consumer Reports prominently covered fixed fee proposals from the perspective of rates and affordability, as did the Wall Street Journal.
The growing visibility of the issue came to a head at this year’s annual meeting of the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC). Compared with the 2014 meeting (which had only one panel on the issue, relegated to a Sunday subcommittee), in 2015 rate design, fixed charges, and the pressing need for smarter, more inclusive approaches dominated the conversation. A provocative new report was also released at the meeting that put an additional nail in the fixed fee coffin. The sustainable business group, Ceres, released “Pathways to a 21st Century Utility” authored by Peter Kind who had previously recommended in a 2013 Edison Electric Institute (EEI) paper (“Disruptive Challenges”) that utilities address revenue erosion with fixed fee hikes. But now, two years later, Mr. Kind has profoundly reversed course and recommends that utilities shift away from this approach and toward innovative rate designs that accommodate the changing electric grid.
As Utility Dive quipped, “as quickly as fixed charges came into vogue, they now appear to be on the way out.”
As we near the end of 2015, more signs abound that the fixed fee trend is losing ground. Even the Wisconsin commission, the outlier in this discussion, is taking notice. In a relative shift from their 2014 decisions, just a few weeks ago commissioners scaled back a fixed fee request from Wisconsin Public Service Corporation and ordered a study on their impacts on consumers. Building on a foundation that includes a joint statement between NRDC and EEI last year, the utility trade organization has also expressed interest in working with the environmental and consumer communities and discussing alternative rate designs that can command broad agreement. NRDC and others are exploring decoupling (which as of this year is being implemented in over half the states), minimum bills, and well-designed time of use rates with appropriate customer protections.
What Comes Next? 2016 and Beyond
There can be no doubt: 2015 was a wildly successful year for pushback on these regressive rate proposals.
But our work isn’t done.
While the national conversation is shifting away from fixed fees to other rate structures, state-level utility proposals to increase these fees are still coming. We’ll continue to fight in 2016 to ensure they don’t gain traction and to encourage commissioners to demand more innovative solutions from the utilities they regulate.
As for utilities, we challenge the industry to choose a better path. There are smarter ways to modernize and keep pace with transitions in the energy marketplace. Let’s work together to design 21st century electric rates that focus on affordability, efficiency and expanding access to the kinds of clean, renewable energy that people are demanding.
We think 2016 will be another banner year.
by jboullion | Dec 3, 2015 | Uncategorized
For immediate release
December 3, 2015
More Information
Tyler Huebner, Executive Director
RENEW Wisconsin Statement on Public Service Commission Approving $14 Monthly Fixed Charge for Xcel Energy
In today’s open meeting, the Public Service Commission approved a hike in monthly mandatory fixed charges for residential customers of Xcel Energy in Wisconsin, from $8 per month (today) to $14 per month starting next year, a 75% increase. The company had been seeking an $18 monthly charge.
“Although we are happy that Xcel Energy customers will not face the full $18 monthly charge, this is still a 75% increase in mandatory fixed charges that is exceptionally higher than what utilities in other states are being granted by state regulators,” said Tyler Huebner, Executive Director of RENEW Wisconsin. “Over 500 individuals and organizations made their voices heard opposing this change, and their efforts helped educate the Commissioners about the impacts this change will have on their lives.”
RENEW Wisconsin conducted analysis of fixed charge requests by similar utilities throughout the country in 2014 and 2015. Of 35 proposals identified:
– 14 were rejected entirely, including Xcel’s Minnesota operation which requested an increase from $8 to just $9.25 earlier in 2015
– 18 utilities were granted increases below $4.30, with an average hike of $2.13.
– Only 3 were granted higher increases, all in Wisconsin. Today’s decision adds a fourth.
“Rate designs with a high fixed charge punish those customers who can least afford to pay more for their electricity. They take away the ability to control one’s utility bills, and they make it harder for customers to save money through conservation measures and more efficient appliances. This is at bottom an issue of consumer fairness,” said Huebner.
For more analysis of this issue, please visit http://midwestenergynews.com/2015/12/04/wisconsin-regulators-approves-another-fixed-charge-increase/
by jboullion | Nov 24, 2015 | Uncategorized
For immediate release
November 24, 2015
More Information
Tyler Huebner, Executive Director
608.255.4044
tyler.huebner@renewwisconsin.org
Madison Community Foundation Supports New RENEW Wisconsin Endowment for an Energy Analysis and Policy Student Intern

RENEW Wisconsin (RENEW) has been awarded a 33% cost sharing grant of $34,000 from the Madison Community Foundation. The grant will fund a
perpetual endowment to support a UW-Madison Energy Analysis and Policy
(EAP) student intern working at RENEW.
“This grant is a perfect match between RENEW and the UW-Madison’s EAP program supporting RENEW’s renewable energy policy research. The Madison Community Foundation support allows us to permanently hire an impassioned student from one of the top energy graduate programs in the country to analyze policies that will spur the use of clean renewable energy in Wisconsin,” said Tyler Huebner, RENEW’s executive director.
RENEW has a history of hiring EAP student interns who have worked on cutting edge renewable policy issues such as third party financing, utility rate cases, community solar, and more.
Don Wichert, a major donor to the endowment, RENEW Board Member, and 1987 graduate of the EAP program, praised the Madison Community Foundation in supporting this permanent support of the EAP program. “This grant will help RENEW leverage other EAP alumni and RENEW member support setting up a great opportunity to work together for RENEW and the EAP program. This program will allow the EAP program to recruit the top students in the country to work on cutting edge renewable policy issues with RENEW,” said Wichert.
“This project furthers two of the Madison Community Foundation’s key goals – to help steward the environment and to inspire philanthropy. RENEW Wisconsin’s endowment campaign will create a sustainable fund to attract bright students and help them develop real world experience through critical analytical and policy analysis. It is a perfect way to celebrate RENEW’s 25th anniversary and enrich their environmental programming,” said Tom Linfield, Madison Community Foundation Vice President of Community Impact.
—–End—-
RENEW Wisconsin leads and accelerates the transformation to Wisconsin’s renewable energy future through advocacy, education, and collaboration.
Madison Community Foundation uses its local knowledge and assets to inspire giving, support meaningful initiatives, and connect people for the common good. Since 1942, foundation staff have helped people realize their philanthropic goals, allowing them to support charitable interested anywhere in the world. The community foundation also awards grants throughout Dane County to build communities. More information is available online at www.madison comunityfoundation.org.
by jboullion | Nov 19, 2015 | Uncategorized
For immediate release
November 19, 2015
More Information
Tyler Huebner, Executive Director
608.255.4044
tyler.huebner@renewwisconsin.org
Public Service Commission Sharply Trims WPS’ Fixed Charge Request
State regulatory agency grants Wisconsin Public Service only a $2 monthly increase instead of the $6 requested
In today’s open meeting, the Public Service Commission sharply trimmed Green Bay-based Wisconsin Public Service’s request to increase monthly mandatory charges on small electricity customers from $19 to $25. Instead, the Commission settled on a $2/month increase, to $21/month, while agreeing to study the issue in greater depth.
One year earlier, the Commission approved a request from WPS to hike its mandatory fixed charge from $10.40 to $19 per month for residential and other small customers.
Commissioners Phil Montgomery and Mike Huebsch initially signaled interest in granting no increase at all. A compromise was reached with Chairperson Ellen Nowak to increase the fixed charge by $2 per month, to $21, a 10% increase.
“We are pleased that the Commission has slowed down and granted a much smaller fixed charge increase than what WPS had requested,” said Tyler Huebner, RENEW Wisconsin’s Executive Director. “This sends a signal that the Commission is responding to customers who have expressed a wide variety of concerns about these high fixed charges. In fact, 368 people voiced their opinion publicly and none supported higher fixed charges. We hope the analysis that’s conducted by the Commission leads to a broader discussion of how to design rates in a way that leads us towards an energy future that benefits all of Wisconsin.”
“Rate designs with high fixed charges punish those customers who can least afford to pay more for their electricity. They take away the ability to control one’s utility bills, and they make it harder for customers to save money through conservation measures and more efficient appliances. This is at bottom an issue of consumer fairness, and many more consumers than usual spoke up,” said Huebner.
In the rate case, RENEW presented research demonstrating that regulators in other states were not supportive of utility requests to hike fixed charges.
See more at: http://www.renewwisconsin-blog.org/2015/10/robin-hood-in-reverse-is-back-wps.html
by jboullion | Nov 18, 2015 | Uncategorized
Today, Madison Gas & Electric announced a framework that includes expanding the company’s investment in renewable energy to meet 30% of their electricity needs by the year 2030.
In addition, the company indicates a plan to give customers more control, and continue to engage the customers and communities they serve going forward.
“This new framework is a good step forward for Madison Gas & Electric Company and for the communities they serve. MG&E’s goals of providing 25% renewable energy by 2025 and 30% by 2030 are achievable,” said Tyler Huebner, Executive Director of RENEW Wisconsin.
“We agree that ongoing collaboration will be needed to identify the best ways to meet the goals of this new framework. Ensuring customer opportunities to invest in renewable energy and energy efficiency, and incorporating equity, fairness, and control over
customer bills, should continue to be part of the conversation and collaboration going forward.”
MGE has made more information available at mge.com/Energy2030.